I joined my first social media site in 2009. I have since joined many others, most for business, some for fun. My experiences on these sites over the past five years have opened my eyes to a stereotype I never knew existed (and there are many in my field) – the stereotype that editors are strict, A-type personalities who are sticklers for the rules.
Critiquing Personal Messages?
I enjoy meeting people from around the world and I have met dozens online. Some are fellow writers or avid readers who understand and are interested in what I do to make a living. But there is a small minority who are frightened to hear I am a writer and editor.
Most people I never hear from again when they learn my profession. There have been a few, however, who have written me expressing fear that I am critiquing everything they type. I will admit I do notice errors; the grammar filter in my brain can’t be turned off once its been activated. But noticing errors doesn’t mean that I’m going to point them out or judge a person’s character based on them. If a person’s not a paying customer, this would succeed in doing me no good anyway.
I will admit, though, that I do have some email pet peeves that I feel make communication difficult.
These pet peeves are:
- Not punctuating the end of sentences.
- Not capitalizing sentences.
- Not using paragraphs.
Nay, It is I Who Is Critiqued
Instead I am the one who is critiqued. When people are aware that I should know better, they are very eager to point out mistakes I make in social media forums, places where speaking casually is encouraged, and other places.
I will never forget the time I was taunted mercilessly by two other editors in a LinkedIn group. I felt like I was back in school, being bullied for every move I made. Needless to say, I left that group. It did not have a safe, professional atmosphere. Still, I did not give up and do something else for a living, as the naysayers told me I needed to. I stuck with it, knowing I was better than the one social media post they were judging.
Periodically, I will receive messages from people, again critiquing what I had to say about something. Thankfully, most have been polite.
All the constant criticism sometimes makes me nervous about posting on “A Writer’s Life”. I know the naysayers are out there, ready to pounce.
What are some stereotypes you’ve encountered about your profession, and how has it affected how you deal with others?
Latest posts by Melina Druga (see all)
- Erich Maria Remarque’s All Quiet on the Western Front - September 26, 2017
- The Committee on Public Information - August 28, 2017
- World War I Led to Prohibition - August 14, 2017