Canada’s federal election of 1917 was a vicious, heated contest. This speaks volumes considering the 1911 election had enough rhetoric, half truths and mudslinging to make a 21st century politician feel right at home. (This post is a companion piece to Melina Druga’s WWI Trilogy, Angel of Mercy, Those Left Behind and Adjustment Year, available wherever eBooks are sold.)
The election was fought primarily with one issue in mind: conscription. For this reason, it also is known as the Khaki Election.
It was held Dec. 17, less than two weeks after the Halifax Explosion. The opponents were the Unionists (comprised of the Conservatives, some Liberals and a few Independents) and the Liberals.
Liberals who remained loyal to Laurier were referred to as Laurier Liberals. Those who aligned themselves with Borden were called Liberal-Unionists.
Military Service Act
By mid-1917, 130,000 Canadians had been killed or wounded in World War I. This staggering casualty rate, along with a sharp decrease in volunteers, meant it was becoming more difficult to replace the men who were lost.
Borden visited the troops overseas and became convinced the only solution was to enact conscription. This view countered an earlier promise to not make military service compulsory. It was, however, a view that was popular in the majority of the country.
French-speaking Quebec had been against the war from the beginning. When the Military Service Act was proposed, there were riots throughout the province.
Pro-conscription supporters in Quebec faced violence while farmers, who were against both parties, were accused of price gouging and profiteering.
Borden approached Laurier about forming a pro-conscription, coalition government, but Laurier refused. So, two months before the election, Borden formed the Union party.
The war ended before the Military Service Act could have its intended effect. Only 24,000 men would serve overseas of the 125,000 who were called up.
Wartime Elections Act
Another issue weighing on the public’s mind was the Wartime Elections Act.
- Allowed soldiers to vote during wartime. They had previously been excluded.
- Enfranchised women who were serving in the medical corps.
- Enfranchised the mothers, spouses and sisters of men serving overseas.
- Disenfranchised immigrants from enemy nations who had arrived in Canada from 1902 onward unless the immigrant had a brother, son or grandson serving in active service.
- Disenfranchised anyone who would be exempt from conscription, primarily conscientious objectors who would be more likely to vote Liberal.
The Liberals opposed the tactics the Conservatives/Unionists used to gain votes, but were powerless to stop the act’s passage.
The act was repealed before Armistice. Women, however, were unaffected. All women older than 21 permanently gained the federal vote.
Political advertisements and speakers presented the election as a choice between the current government and the opposition. A vote for the government, they said, was a vote for the soldiers and killing the Kaiser. A vote for the opposition, on the other hand, was a vote for slackers and an endorsement of the enemy.
The Unionists won nearly 57 percent of the vote. They took 153 of the 235 open seats. Only 20 Liberal seats were won outside of Quebec.
Half a million women voted for the first time.
The federal election of 1917 has been called Canada’s ugliest election.
Updated: 20 October 2020